April 8, 2025

The Unraveling of a 50-Year-Old Mystery: Karen Percifield’s Murderer Identified

Community Resource Consultants Inc. (CRCI)

Community Resource Consultants Inc. (CRCI) is a Michigan-based organization specializing in trauma rehabilitation medical case management. With over 34 years of experience, CRCI is dedicated to empowering survivors of catastrophic auto accidents to regain control of their lives and achieve both physical and emotional well-being. Their team of Licensed Master Social Workers (LMSWs) and Registered Nurses (RNs) are experts in navigating the complexities of today’s healthcare system, ensuring that survivors receive the necessary services for their recovery and rehabilitation. CRCI’s core values include advocacy, people, knowledge, and dependability, reflecting their commitment to being leading advocates and facilitators of long-term collaborative care.

News Summary

After nearly 50 years, the identity of Karen Percifield’s murderer has been uncovered thanks to advancements in DNA technology. Initially a cold case from 1976, the finding not only brings closure to her family but also highlights the importance of forensic science in solving historical mysteries.

The Unraveling of a 50-Year-Old Mystery: Karen Percifield’s Murderer Identified

It’s a story that reads like a crime novel, but for the family of Karen Percifield, who was discovered dead in 1976, it has been a painful reality for nearly half a century. Thanks to groundbreaking DNA technology, the identity of her killer has finally come to light.

The Case That Haunted a Family

Karen Percifield was just 25 years old when she went missing from a popular hotel during a visit to see her sister. In May 1976, after an argument with her mother, she went for a walk and failed to return. Days turned into seemingly endless hours of agony for her loved ones until the discovery of her body in a ravine sent shockwaves through the community. Tragically, Percifield had been stabbed to death, leaving a void in the hearts of those who knew and loved her.

A Long Wait for Justice

Initially, significant suspicion pointed towards Richard Sommerhalder, who emerged as a person of interest immediately after the murder. However, despite the evidence linking him to the crime, investigators found themselves lacking the necessary proof to press charges. Sommerhalder’s past only thickened the plot as he was later convicted in connection with the murders of two other women and ultimately served 8.5 years in prison before being paroled and relocating out of state. He passed away in 1994, leaving the Percifield family without closure and Sommerhalder without accountability.

Advancements Change the Game

Fast forward to 2019, when detectives took the bold step of re-examining evidence in this cold case. The team submitted samples for DNA testing, but an initial search through the database turned up empty. With Sommerhalder’s death hindering their efforts to obtain his DNA for comparison, the investigation seemed stalled once again. However, thanks to advances in genetic genealogy and the hard work of dedicated forensic scientists, a breakthrough was finally achieved.

A Breakthrough in Technology

Othram Laboratories played a crucial role in turning the tides of this long-standing mystery. Their innovative techniques allowed for the analysis of hundreds of thousands of DNA markers as opposed to the mere 20-24 markers used in traditional testing methods. It was through this meticulous analysis that Sommerhalder was ultimately re-identified as the killer, bringing a long-overdue resolution to Percifield’s case.

Finding Closure

For Percifield’s family, the identification of her murderer provided a sense of relief after years of uncertainty and heartache. Her daughter, Meadow Shumake, expressed profound gratitude for the resolution of the case, finally lifting the heavy weight of ambiguity surrounding her mother’s tragic death. Additionally, Percifield’s sister, Annie Goheen, reflected on the lengthy journey toward closure, emphasizing the significance of modern advancements in DNA technology in unraveling such historical mysteries.

A Nod to Dedication and the Future of Forensics

The Santa Cruz County Sheriff’s Office has been lauded for their unwavering commitment to solving this long-forgotten case, reiterating that the search for the truth never truly ends, no matter how much time has elapsed. District Attorney Jeff Rosell praised the team’s efforts, pointing out how the case’s resolution showcases the transformative power of forensic science in addressing cold cases.

A Bright Future for Cold Cases

With this latest identification marking the 59th case solved in California through Othram’s forensic expertise, the company is now extending its capabilities from cold cases to contemporary investigations, offering hope for families searching for answers after decades of silence. The powerful combination of advanced technology and relentless dedication unveils the ever-growing potential to solve even the most perplexing unsolved crimes.

While it’s a bittersweet resolution for those who miss Karen Percifield, her case serves as a reminder of the importance of perseverance in the quest for justice. Every advancement brings us one step closer to bringing comfort and closure to families longing for truth.